Pizza Pleasure: The Top Three Toppings

We love pizza here at Shirley Sub Shoppe. Everyone has their own preferences and thoughts about what belongs on a pizza, but there are some toppings that stay popular year after year. The top three in the United States are pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms.


Pepperoni Pleasure: A Timeless Classic

Pepperoni is the undisputed champion of pizza toppings. The thin slices of cured, spicy Italian sausage perfectly complement the gooey mozzarella cheese and tangy tomato sauce. The alluring aroma and irresistible crispiness that pepperoni brings to the table have stood the test of time. Each bite is a harmony of savory and slightly spicy notes, creating an experience that is both comforting and exciting. Pepperoni isn’t just a topping; it’s a tradition that Shirley Sub Shoppe lovingly upholds, satisfying cravings and warming hearts.


Sausage Sensation: A Hearty Indulgence

If you’re seeking a hearty and satisfying pizza experience, you can’t go wrong with sausage. This savory masterpiece, often crafted from a blend of seasoned pork, herbs, and spices, delivers a rich and robust flavor that resonates with pizza aficionados. With every slice, the succulent sausage crumbles into the melted cheese, infusing each bite with a rustic, down-home charm. Paired with our signature crust, this topping takes taste buds on a journey of pure indulgence.


Mushroom Magic: Earthy Elegance

We now bring a touch of sophistication to the pizza world with the inclusion of earthy and delectable mushrooms. This topping elevates the culinary experience by providing a unique textural contrast and a flavor profile that is both subtle and enchanting. Sautéed to perfection, the mushrooms offer a velvety richness that harmonizes exquisitely with the other ingredients. As a vegetarian-friendly option, mushroom-topped pizza reflects the diversity of tastes that we embrace, ensuring everyone can enjoy the perfect food: pizza.


Enjoy All Your Favorite Pizza Toppings at Shirley Sub Shoppe

Whether these top three toppings are in your top three, or you have your own personal favorites, you’ll love the pizza from Shirley Sub Shoppe! From meat lovers to vegetarians and everything in between, everyone can satisfy their cravings with us! And if—somehow—you’re not in the mood for pizza, we have pasta, sandwiches, salads, and more! There’s something for everyone on our menu, so come enjoy lunch or dinner with us today!


Visit us at 1 Front Street in Shirley or order online!

Try our New App!

5% off your first order when you join our rewards program!